How to Hire a WordPress SEO Company (and What to Ask First)
By Lincoln M · · Updated 11/12/2026
To hire a WordPress SEO company, start with the problem you need solved, then look for a team that can handle both sides of it: the WordPress development work (speed, custom themes and plugins, Core Web Vitals) and the SEO work (technical SEO, content and local search). Ask for real examples, a clear scope and a monthly report before you sign anything.
Picking a package off a list from any web development company won’t help if it doesn’t match what’s actually holding your website back.
Figure Out What Problem You’re Facing
Before you contact a WordPress developer or SEO agency, write down what isn’t working. Is the site slow on mobile? Are your key pages missing from Google search results? Do visitors leave without calling? Is your email marketing disconnected from the site?
A good WordPress SEO company asks these questions first. We review the site, its Google Search Console data and the client’s goals before suggesting any WordPress services, so the plan targets the real bottleneck instead of a long list of extras.
If you’re weighing a cheap marketplace gig, the video below, about ordering a $100 website on Fiverr, is worth a watch before you decide.
What WordPress SEO Agencies Should Handle
WordPress is flexible, but that flexibility cuts both ways. Bloated themes, too many plugins and messy code can drag down rankings and user experience. Whoever you hire, the right WordPress experts cover:
Technical SEO: crawlability, site structure, schema, redirects and Core Web Vitals. Our technical SEO checklist shows what that involves.
WordPress development: custom WordPress themes, plugin development in PHP and JavaScript, WooCommerce for e-commerce, and safe updates to WordPress core.
On-page SEO: titles, headings, internal links and content that matches what people search for.
Local SEO: Google Business Profile and location pages if you serve a specific area.
Maintenance: backups, security monitoring and fixing broken WordPress plugins.
That’s the scope of our WordPress SEO services: one team for the website and the rankings.
Choose WordPress Services That Solve Your Problems
Once the problems are clear, tie each fix to the bottom line. How much time would better collaboration save? What happens to sales if an email strategy improves customer retention? What would each new lead cost if you grow your search engine visibility, and what’s that lead worth over time?
Answering those questions tells you which WordPress services are worth paying for. We’d rather focus on one or two areas with real promise than sell a stack of disconnected tools that leave you going in circles.
Questions to Ask Before Hiring a WordPress Developer or SEO Agency
Can you show WordPress websites you’ve built or improved, and what changed afterward?
Who does the work: in-house WordPress experts, freelance WordPress developers or an outsourced team?
What’s included each month, and how will you report progress?
Can you speed up my existing WordPress site, or does it need a rebuild?
Who owns the site, the content and the accounts if we stop working together?
Be wary of anyone who promises first-page rankings by a set date. Nobody controls Google’s results. A good SEO company explains what it will do, why, and how it measures progress.
Freelance WordPress Developer or Agency?
Hiring a freelance WordPress developer on a platform like Upwork or Fiverr can work for a small, well-defined fix. For ongoing SEO and WordPress web development, an agency gives you dedicated WordPress developers plus web design, content and SEO under one roof, so you aren’t coordinating five contractors.
Valuable WordPress Services Don’t Mean Free
Some of the add-on ideas in this post can have a big impact on the two resources every business owner cares about most: time and money.
If a service saves time or brings in revenue, it’s worth paying for, and it’s an easier call when it comes from a developer you already trust.
Looking to hire a WordPress SEO company in New York? Sleek Web Designs is a Brooklyn-based web design and SEO agency with over a decade in business, rated 5.0 on Google, serving NYC’s five boroughs and New Jersey. We build WordPress sites for Google and optimize them for AI search tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews. Start with a free SEO audit or call (347) 416-5655.
Website accessibility fixes can remove the barriers that stop visitors from calling, requesting a quote or booking a service. A contact form without clear labels, a menu that…
If people can find your website but cannot quickly call you, your business phone number is not doing its job. For a local service business, that number is…